Psychological egoism elliott sober psycliological egoism is a theory about motivation that claims that all of our ulti mate desires are selfdirected. They say that people have no choice but to be selfish, in some way. Feinbergs critique psychological egoism view that all. Not everyone is selfinterested why psychological egoism is. Psychological egoism is a descriptive theory that rather than suggesting, as ethical or rational egoism does, how people ought to live, suggests how people actually go about their lives. Whenever we want others to do well or ill, we have these otherdirected desires only instrumentally. Psychological egoism by joel feinberg philosophercharlie. He is the author of ethics for a brave new world with paul d. Psychological egoism is the thesis that we are always deep down motivated by. It clarifies that selfishness is not about doing whatever you feel like. Brigham young university 5222 may 20 with 3,188 reads.
The concepts of justice rawls and rights feinberg are explored, as well as recent views on the importance of virtue ethics rachels and an ethic influenced by feminist concerns held. Classical and contemporary readings sixth edition belmont. It claims that, when people choose to help others, they do so ultimately because of the personal benefits that they themselves expect to obtain, directly or indirectly, from so doing. Phil 101 ethical egoism and psychological egoism 17 terms. Every single kind action has a dirty, secret story behind it. Psychological egoism vs ethical egoism flow psychology. Ethical egoism states that we morally ought to be promoting self interest, but in respects to promote others good if need be. The tendency to engage in prosocial behaviour and the personal motives behind our actions thesis pdf available august 2015. Feinberg was one of the most influential figures in american jurisprudence of the last. Selfinterest, ethical egoism, and the restored gospel article pdf available in brigham young university studies. Pearson offers special pricing when you package your text with other student resources. It must be distinguished from the normative claim that.
Psychological egoism proposes that humanity is only capable of pursuing his. Feinberg points out reasons to support the theory, but the majority of the time he critiques and points out its various flaws. Max stirners egoism max stirners egoism jenkins, john 20090301 00. Rational egoism subscribing to ethical egoism because its the most reasonable of the ethical theories, the one a perfectly rational person would choose. On this view, even though all actions are regarded as selfinterested actions, the egoist readily points out that people usually try to conceal the determining motives for their actions because such concealment is usually in their selfinterest. A more commonly held subset of this belief is psychological egoistic hedonism, which says that we only act for our own pleasure. What is psychological egoism, and how does it differ from ethical egoism. The tendency to engage in prosocial behaviour and the personal motives behind our actions thesis pdf available august 2015 with 3,1 reads how we. Feinberg observes that such arguments for psychological egoism are rarely mounted on the basis of empirical proof when, being psychological, they very well ought to. The essay was originally composed by professor feinberg for his students in 1958, and appeared regularly in his reason and responsibility of which there were many editions.
Joel feinberg psychological egoism for california high school. Joel feinberg october 19, 1926 in detroit, michigan march 29, 2004 in tucson, arizona was an american political and legal philosopher. Do you agree with the verdict he draws from the story. Master and slave morality 547 proposed standards of right conduct 555 russ shaferlandau. According to joel feinberg there are some points that have made psychological egoism plausible to many people. It explains the difference between motivation and selfinterest. The final volume of feinbergs fourvolume work, the moral limits of criminal law examines the philosophical basis for the criminalization of socalled victimless crimes such as ticket scalping, blackmail, consentedto exploitation of others, commercial fortune telling, and. View notes feinbergs critique from phil 160 at university of kansas. Of particular interest to me is the paradox of hedonism. Joel feinberg psychological egoism for california high. The psychological egoist confuses egoistic desires with motivation. Joshua may 2011 european journal of philosophy 19 1. View that all human conduct is selfishly motivated.
Dec 08, 20 psychological egoism is the belief that men only act in selfinterest in all situations, and when we help others we do it for ourselves. The first part, historical sources, moves from classical thought plato, aristotle, epicurus, and epictetus through medieval views augustine. Ethical egoism holds, therefore, that actions whose consequences will. As feinberg states, an exclusive desire for happiness is the surest way to prevent happiness from coming into being. The biggest problem with psychological egoism is tha. Not everyone is selfinterested why psychological egoism. However, like you said, any action becomes fundamentally selfish, which, is precisely what that theory is stating. The only thing that anyone is capable of desiring pursuing ultimately as an end itself is his own selfinterest. Mar 11, 2007 what may not be evident from the title of this post is that im fairly sure that there is an equivocation in feinbergs infinite regress argument against psychological egoism. Harm to self, tucson joel feinberg professor of philosophy university of arizona, jul 24, 1986, law, 448 pages. History, theory, and contemporary issues, third edition, is organized into three parts, providing instructors with flexibility in designing and teaching a variety of courses in moral philosophy. Feinberg clarifies psychological egoism and maintains that there are several things wrong with this theory. This appears in section c of his article psychological egoism in the popular anthology reason and responsibility 12th ed.
Joel feinberg presents a multitude of arguments against psychological egoistic hedonism. The assumptive nature of the theory introduces a number of possible avenues for refutation, some of which are very compelling. Chapter starts off with a dialogue between edna egoist and alan altruist. The opening argument he dubs a tautology from which nothing whatever concerning the nature of my motives or the objective of my desires can possibly follow. We have no choice but to act selfishly, as we cant be motivated any other way. Many people today believe that everyone is selfinterested at all times. Human agents always, at least on a deepdown level, are all egoists insofar as our behavior, explainable in terms of our beliefs and desires, is always aimed at what we believe is our greatest good baier, 1991, p. This is the third volume of joel feinbergs highly regarded the moral limits of the criminal law, a fourvolume series in which feinberg skillfully addresses a complex question. What is feinberg s point in telling the story about abraham lincoln. If youre interested in creating a costsaving package for your students, contact your pearson rep.
What is feinbergs point in telling the story about abraham lincoln. It holds that all desires are egoistic desires, or else derived egoistic desires. Hicks egoism in nietzsche and rand 251 the bottom of all these noble races the beast of prey, the splendid blond beast, prowling about avidly in search of spoil and victory. And the problems they raise apply equally to butlerstyle arguments against psychological egoism generally. The selfishness or unselfishness of an action is to be determined objectively. The most comprehensive collection of its kind, ethics. What do you think is the best argument in favor of the theory. Psychological egoism psychological egoism is the thesis that we always act from selfish motives. Psychological egoism psychological egoism, whose proponents include epicurus, hobbes, spinoza, and arguably bentham, and whose critics include butler, hume, and sidgwick, is a doctrine about human nature, and speci. Psychological egoists claim that lincoln acted on the sow purely for the selfish pleasure.
Unlike ethical egoism, psychological egoism is merely an empirical claim about what kinds of. Feinberg phd, university of chicago is department chair and professor of biblical and systematic theology at trinity evangelical divinity school. May 06, 2018 its specifically on this issue of psychological egoism. Feinberg thd, dallas theological seminary was professor of. Psychological egoism is the position that the ultimate motive of all actions is selfish.
In this chapter i shall discuss arguments that have been given for the strong form of ethical egoism. Psychological egoism cannot be true because at least some human activity is done to ultimately advance the welfare of others, and there is insufficient evidence to warrant the claim that all human behavior is motivated purely out of self interest. What may not be evident from the title of this post is that im fairly sure that there is an equivocation in feinbergs infinite regress argument against psychological egoism. Pdf selfinterest, ethical egoism, and the restored gospel. The beliefs on egoism in relation to human behavior as for the psychological egoism vs.
Among the subjects that have been part of it is the topic about psychological egoism vs. While psychological egoism on the other hand states that we act in selfinterest. It differs from psychological egoism, which claims that people can only act in their selfinterest. On the relation between psychological and ethical egoism. Ethical egoism the need to describe or establish ground rules on how people behave or ought to behave led studentshare our website is a unique platform where students can share their papers in a matter of giving an example of the work to be done. Psychological egoism is the doctrine that the only thing anyone is capable of desiring or pursuing ultimately is. Feinberg and rachels both play fast and loose with these distinctions. Feinberg and is general editor of crossways foundations of evangelical theology series paul d. The biggest problem with psychological egoism is that. Im getting married with a super, rich, old dude so i can be superduper rich later. The argument you made is to disagree with psychological egoism. The final volume of feinberg s fourvolume work, the moral limits of criminal law examines the philosophical basis for the criminalization of socalled victimless crimes such as ticket scalping, blackmail, consentedto exploitation of others, commercial fortune telling, and consensual sexual relations. In the following two chapters i discuss arguments that have been given against it.
Psychological egoism and selfinterest reason papers. Feinberg essay psychological egoism is an essay written by joel feinberg, which discusses the meaning and controversy over psychological egoism. Ethical egoism also differs from rational egoism, which holds that it is rational to act in ones selfinterest. Relational desires and empirical evidence against psychological egoism. In the third part, contemporary moral problems, the readings present the current debates over abortion, euthanasia, famine relief, animal rights, the death. Psychological egoism is the belief that men only act in selfinterest in all situations, and when we help others we do it for ourselves. He is known for his work in the fields of ethics, action theory, philosophy of law, and political philosophy as well as individual rights and the authority of the state. Ethical egoism is the normative ethical position that moral agents ought to act in their own selfinterest.
Equivocation in feinbergs infinite regress argument. Theory of psychological egoism asserts that each person does in fact pursue his or her own selfinterest exclusively. This simply means that individuals, when faced with a moral dilemma, should consider which of their options will protect, benefit, or serve their own self. It is not determined by the feelings of the person who acts. Despite the many obscurities and complexities surrounding stirners conception of self. Psychological egoism is the thesis that we are always deep down motivated by what we perceive to be in our own selfinterest.
Psychological egoism is the empirical doctrine that the determining motive of every voluntary action is a desire for ones own welfare. Psychological egoism psychological egoism is the doctrine that the only thing anyone is capable of desiring or pursuing ultimately is a. Psychological egoism is the thesis that we always act from selfish motives. I will be defending this thesis, and my opponents objective should be to show that there are instances where a person acts with with purely altruistic motives. At least some human activity is done to ultimately advance the welfare of others.
Ethical egoism is a form of morality that states that all moral decisions should be made to benefit selfinterest. Bibliography of joel feinberg, the journal of ethics 10. If altruism is true than ethical egoism could still be true while psychological egoism would be false. We have friends because we like the satisfaction of having friends. Psychological egoism is a descriptive theory and as such is fully open to refutation. This is a doctrine of human nature thats been around for centuries, and its called psychological egoism. Psychological egoism is the view that humans are always motivated by selfinterest and selfishness, even in what seem to be acts of altruism. Psychological egoism is a claim about all intentional actions. It says, roughly, that human beings are so constituted as to.
760 1075 1184 192 993 101 74 68 1218 452 400 1297 648 667 296 567 1202 957 1261 999 1373 338 860 285 962 579 1476 771 1449 314 92 922 547 1266 308 1038 172 557 622 1282 1092 993 386 726 1228 1064 1306 186 902